Est. Reading: 2 minutes
09/18

Which Project Management Methodology is Right for you?

Co-Founder & Director
Co-Founder & Director
Christian has over 20 years of experience recruiting and leading high growth recruitment companies in London. He Co-founded The Consultancy Group in 2015 to service the world of Commerce & Industry with experienced Finance, Tax, Transformation and Software Engineering Individuals across London and Europe. With a particular oversight of our Transformation business, Christian is focused on growing our Consultancy practice across the following disciplines; Finance Transformation, Digital Transformation, HR & Organisational Change, Business Intelligence & Data Analytics and DevOps.

There are a number of different project management methodologies around and they all have one thing in common: to help manage a team’s work processes via rules, structure and communication to ultimately reach the completion of a project. However, despite this same goal and their similar sounding jargon, they all have significantly different methods that set them apart. Looking at four of the most successful, what are the differences between Waterfall, Agile, Kanban and Scrum, and which should you choose?

Waterfall

Initially, we should consider the first two, as they are fundamentally different. Waterfall is one of the oldest project management methods around, originating in Construction and Manufacturing where each part of a project is dependent on the previous part being completed. It can only be used in this linear fashion, where a project moves from one phase to the next and you cannot revisit a previous phase. It is a very structured way of completing a project with stages agreed in advance, so if working simultaneously or requiring flexibility is your preferred method, it’s not for you.

Agile

Agile is the opposite of Waterfall – allowing flexible, simultaneous workflows – and projects are broken down into smaller subsets. This works best for teams who may adapt their process if the project requirements change, or on projects that need regular revisions or testing, such as software development. Team members can stop and change direction without disrupting the project.

Kanban

Both Kanban and Scrum are really specific types of Agile methodology, adhering to those flexible principles rather than the rigid Waterfall ones, but each with their own ways of implementing them. Kanban’s primary feature is about improving team processes. It uses a Kanban board to show incremental work in progress through to completion, helping teams visualise bottlenecks or where problems in their process lie. It allows teams to easily adjust and correct their workflow processes to keep projects on track efficiently. 

Scrum

While Kanban is all about the process, Scrum is all about speed. Projects are broken down and planned into short “sprints” – set time periods where certain elements of the project will be completed – by a Scrum Master facilitator. There are daily meetings on progress to ensure that everyone is on the same page and it also has its own visualisation method to show a live status to all team members.

Choosing a methodology depends on how your team works best and the nature of the project. Each has its own restrictions and advantages, depending on whether speed, process or workflow is most important. The crucial thing is selecting a method and sticking to it – they are not interchangeable and in fact using elements of more than one would have the adverse effect and most likely slow a team and its project down. 

If you need project management expertise in any of the above methodologies for your team, contact us today.

Recent Job Openings

Finance Transformation Director

The Consultancy Group are currently partnering with a Big 4 Consulting business in search of a Finance Transformation Director with a specialised focus on Order to Cash processes. As a key member of their finance transformation practice, you will play a crucial role in leading and delivering high-impact projects for their clients. Responsibilities: Order to […]
Co-Founder & Director

SAP Architect – Global Media Company

The Consultancy Group are currently supporting a global Media organisation to build out its IT function following the carve-out and separation from the parent company. As part of their Transformation journey, we looking for an Interim SAP Architect to lead the development and execution of SAP solutions for projects Responsibilities: Conducting thorough evaluations of existing […]
Co-Founder & Director

Director of Engineering – Luxury Retail

The Director of Engineering will be responsible for leading the digital transformation efforts for our luxury retail client. In this role, you will be responsible for building out their internal capability and overseeing a team of engineers as they work to double their revenue for digital channels. The ideal candidate will have a proven track […]
Co-Founder & Director

Data Technology & Integration Lead

The Consultancy Group is partnering with a prominent global manufacturing business headquartered in London, with strategic offices across Europe and Singapore. Over the past two decades, the company has executed several strategic acquisitions, resulting in a diverse portfolio of independently functioning entities. The organisation is embarking on a comprehensive Finance Transformation Programme to achieve operational […]
Co-Founder & Director

Subscribe to our newsletter and stay updated.

Newsletter Subscribe - FJ New

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.